Our Drinks: Wine Bar, Craft Cocktails & More
Tap Beer
Black Husky Three Scrutineers
$8.00
Belgian Tripel | 8.5% | Tulip
Bell's Two Hearted Ale
$6.00
IPA | 6.5% | Pint
New Glarus Spotted Cow
$7.00
Cream Ale | 5.1%| Pint
Eagle Park Goon Juice
$9.00
New England/Hazy IPA | 8% | Tulip
Central Waters Mudpuppy
$8.00
Porter | 5%.6 | tulip
Lakefront Riverwest Stein
$6.00
Amber Lager | 6% | Pint
Canned & Bottled Beer
Miller Lite
$4.00
Miller High Life
$4.00
Pabst Blue Ribbon
$4.50
16 oz
Schlitz
$4.50
16 oz
Third Space Happy Place
$5.00
Spotted Cow
$5.00
Modelo Especial
$5.00
Lakefront New Grist
$5.00
Gluten Free
Deschutes Obsidian Stout
$6.00
Downeast Unfiltered Craft Cider
$6.50
Lakefront Bierzeit
$5.00
German Style Kolsch
High Noon Black Cherry
$7.00
Hard Seltzer
High Noon Peach
$7.00
Hard Seltzer
Featured Wine
Il Poggione
$14.00/Glass
$28.00/Retail
$54.00/Bottle
Rosso di Montalcino, Italy, 2019.
Red
Cabernet Sauvignon
$12.00
Wente, Livermore, CA 2018
Malbec
$11.00
Achaval, Mendoza, Argentina 2019
Sangiovese
$11.00
Cecchi, Chianti Classico, Italy 2019
Pinot Noir
$12.00
DeLoach, Russian River, CA 2018
Red Blend
$13.00
Chappellet Mountain Cuveé, Napa Valley CA 2020
Zinfandel
$11.00
Seghesio, Sonoma County, CA 2020
Tempranillo
$11.00
Marques de Marietta, Rioja, Spain 2018
White
Brut Sparkling
$11.00
Scharffenberger, Mendocino, CA
Brut Rosé Sparkling
$12.00
Alma Negra, Mendoza, Argentina
Chardonnay
$11.00
Chateau Buena Vista, Carneros, CA 2019
Sauvignon Blanc
$12.00
Loveblock, Marlborough, New Zealand 2021
Riesling
$10.00
Nik Weis, Mosel, Germany 2021
White Blend
$13.00
Carol Shelton Coquille Blanc, Paso Robles, CA 2020
Rosé
$9.00
Maison No. 9, Méditerranée IGP, France 2019
Pinot Grigio
$11.00
Ruffino Aqua di Venus, Tuscany, Italy 2020
Feature Cocktail
Brotherhood
$12.00
Irish Whiskey, Benedictine D.O.M. Cointreau, Lemon
Classic Cocktails
Sidecar
$12.00
Ansac cognac, cointreau, lemon, sugared rim.
The Last Word
$11.00
Tanqueray gin, green chartreuse, luxardo, lime.
Vesper
$13.00
Bombay gin, Wheatly vodka, Lillet blanc.
Shorewood Shirley
$9.00
Central standard door county cherry vodka, grenadine, sprite.
Rye Manhattan
$11.00
Rittenhouse rye, Carpano Antiqua vermouth, angostura bitters, orange bitters.
Long Island Iced Tea
$10.00
Vodka, Tanqueray Gin, Exotico Tequila, Bacardi Rum, Cointreau, Sour, Coca-Cola
Tap Cocktails
Buttermint Old Fashioned
$9.00
Central standard north Wisconsin brandy, housemade syrup, orange bitters press.
Fall Sangria
$10.00
Red wine, lemon, brandy, cinnamon, spices, orange liquor
Singapore Sling
$10.00
Tanqueray gin, Cherry Heering, Cointreau, Benedictine, pineapple juice, lime
The Original Mai Tai
$11.00
Appleton rum, Cointreau, lime, Orgeat syrup, dark rum float
Dessert Cocktails
Velvet Espresso Martini
$12.00
espresso, vodka, Disaronno Velvet cream
1919 Brandy Alexander
$11.00
Sacred Bond brandy, creme de cacao, cream
The Dude
$10.00
Vodka, Kahlua, cream
Menu
CosNOpolitan
$8.00
Seedlip Grove 42, lime, simple, cranberry juice
French 57
$8.00
Seedlip garden spirit, lemon, simple, N/A sparkling.
Oakland Streetcar
$7.00
Elderflower cordial, grapefruit, lime.
Athletic Brewing Upside Dawn N/A
$5.00
Athletic Brewing Run Wild IPA N/A
$5.00
Lagunitas Hoppy Refresher
$5.00
Leitz Eins Zwei Zero Sparkling Rosé N/A
$11.00
Leitz Eins Zwei Zero Sparkling Riesling N/A
$11.00
Valentine Coffee
$4.00
Valentine Espresso
$3.00
Latte/Cappuccino
$5.00
Rishi Tea
$4.00
Chamomile | Jade Cloud | Tangerine Ginger | Masala Chai
Fresh Brewed Ice Tea
$4.00
Lemonade
$3.50
Soda
$3.50
Coke | Diet Coke | Sprite | Sprite Zero
Point Soda
$3.50
Root Beer | Grape
Enjoy $7 Wine Pours, $8 Tap Cocktails, and $9 Appetizers Tue - Sat 4-6 p.m.
House Happy Hour Wine
Carletto Prosecco (Tap)
$7.00/glass
Prosecco DOC, Veneto, Italy
Gen5 Sauvignon Blanc
$7.00/glass
Sauvignon Blanc, Lodi, CA 2020
Smashberry Red Blend
$7.00/glass
Red Blend, Paso Robles, Santa Maria, CA. 2018
Happy Hour Tap Cocktails
Buttermint Old Fashioned
$8.00
Central Standard North Wisconsin brandy, housemade syrup, orange bitters press
Fall Sangria
$8.00
red wine, lemon, brandy, cinnamon, spices, orange liquor
Singapore Sling
$8.00
Tangqueray gin, Cherry Heering, Cointreau, Benedictine, pineapple juice, lime
The Original Mai Tai
$8.00
Appleton rum, Cointreau, lime, Orgeat syrup, dark rum float
Happy Hour Appetizers
Crispy Chicken XO
$9.00
XO sauce, sesame seaweed salad
Fresh Fried Calamari
$9.00
banana peppers, onions, lemon, preserved lemon aioli (Photo by Angela Peterson/Milwaukee Journal Sentinel)
Chickpea Fries
$9.00
harissa, salt, pepper
Deviled Eggs (3)
$9.00
bacon, tobiko, trout roe
Crispy Pork Rib Nuggets
$9.00
cherry peppers, chili cilantro mayo
Buttermint is open for Weekend Brunch service Saturday-Sunday from 9 a.m-2 p.m.
Essential Beverages
Classic Bloody Mary
$10.00
wheatley vodka, house-made mix, celery, olive, pickle, pils chaser
French 75
$9.00
tanqueray gin, lemon, simple syrup, prosecco
Morning Dove
$10.00
reposado tequila, amaro, lemon, maple syrup
Mimosa
$8.50
prosecco, fresh oj
Aperol Spritz
$10.00
prosecco, aperol, soda, orange
Salty Dog
$8.50
wheatley vodka, fresh grapefruit, salted rim, rosemary
Coffee Alexander
$9.00
brandy, creme de cacao, valentine coffee
Shined-Up Coffee
$8.00
valentine coffee with choice of: bourbon cream, amaretto cream, irish cream, or rumchata
Pumpkin Spice Latte
$6.00
pumpkin puree, espresso, whipped cream, nutmeg & cinnamon
Carmel Apple Cider
$5.00
apple cider, caramel, whipped cream, cinnamon
Apple Cider Mimosa
$9.50
prosecco, apple cider, cinnamon sugar rim
N/A Beverages
Valentine Fresh-Brewed Coffee
$4.00
regular or decaf
Latte or Cappuccino
$5.00
Rishi Chai Latte
$5.50
Fresh OJ
$4.50
Fresh Grapefruit Juice
$4.50
Cranberry Juice
$4.00
Apple Juice
$4.00