Skip to Main Content
Buttermint logo topButtermint logo scroll
  • (414)-488-2587
  • info@blackshoehospitality.com
  • 4195 N Oakland Ave , Shorewood
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • OFF-SITE CATERING
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • RESERVE
Buttermint logo topButtermint logo scroll
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • OFF-SITE CATERING
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • RESERVE

Our Menu

DinnerBrunch

Our Menu Changes Frequently. Items featured here may or may not be available on any given day. Served starting at 5pm Tuesday-Saturday.

Appetizers

Cocktail Meatballs

$14.00
tart cherry demi gastrique, scallions

Bread Service

$9.00
house-made, daily selection, salted butter
Crispy Chicken XO photo

Crispy Chicken XO

$13.00
XO sauce, sesame seaweed salad
Fried Calamari photo

Fried Calamari

$17.00
banana peppers, onions, lemon, preserved lemon aioli (Photo by Angela Peterson/Milwaukee Journal Sentinel)

Chickpea Fries

$13.00
harissa, salt, pepper

Grilled Swordfish Skewers

$15.00
jerk marinated, cilantro & lime rice, sweet chili mango glaze

Raw Bar

Chilled Seafood, Meats, & Vegetables

Smoked Fish Spread

$14.00
warm gougeres, fresh dill, tomato, capers, pickled onion, cucumber

Tombo Sashimi

$16.00
cucumber, carrot, spicy mayo, nori, crunchy bits, ponzu
Oysters of the Day photo

Oysters of the Day

$18.00/6
Chunu - Assateague Island, VA fresh horseradish, house cocktail, lemon

Beet Tartare

$11.00
shallot, capers, rosewater vinaigrette, supremes, gaufrette potatoes, black pepper whipped goat cheese, toasted hazelnuts

Deviled Eggs

$10.00/3
bacon, tobiko, trout roe

Crab Louie Salad

$13.00
sweet cherry tomatoes, deviled egg yolk, house pickles, capers, endive, zesty louie dressing

Smoked Sturgeon Toast

$13.00
buttered challah, egg salad, soy egg, pickled mustard seeds, tobiko, chili mayo, fried shiitake mushrooms, scallions

Salads

Kale and White Bean Salad

$13.00
crispy soppressata, crispy garlic, orange vinaigrette, de-flamed red onion, evalon cheese

House Salad

$6.00/Side Salad
$11.00
mixed greens, bacon, cucumber, tomato, avocado dressing, croutons
Tempura Squash Salad photo

Tempura Squash Salad

$12.00
delicata, arugula, almonds, carrot ginger dressing, buttermilk blue cheese

Roasted Brussels Caesar

$13.00
sumac roasted & shaved brussels sprouts, sunflower seeds, dried cranberry, grana padano

Today's TV Dinner

Available Tuesday-Thursday. Our TV Dinners change frequently.

Today's TV Dinner (Tue-Thu)

$27.00
Walleye Fish Fry Sticks- panko crusted walleye, French fries, tartar sauce, coleslaw, rye bread, warm sour cream donut and berry compote

Entreés

Pan Seared Mahi Mahi

$26.00
roasted garlic polenta cake, confit tomatoes and olives, arugula, red wine sauce, garlic chips

Grilled Swordfish

$38.00
stir-fried butternut squash, apple & cabbage, sticky rice cake, black vinegar, green curry

Steelhead Trout Amandine

$32.00
crispy skin steelhead trout, toasted almond, wild rice pilaf, lemon brown-butter pan sauce, seared haricots verts, crispy shallots

Walleye Fish Fry

$38.00
11 oz panko crusted walleye fillet, potato pancake, apple burro blanc, coleslaw, house tartar sauce, rye bread
Grilled Iowa Pork Rib Chop photo

Grilled Iowa Pork Rib Chop

$36.00
fennel hash, potato croquette, candied bacon, calvados reduction

Roasted Breast of Amish Chicken

$29.00
chicken sausage pelmeni, green beans, baby spinach, marsala sauce

Niman Ranch Burger

$17.00
twin 1/3lb patties, american cheese, L.T.O., house pickles, house bun, fries

Prime Strip Steak au Poivre

$47.00
13 oz CAB beef, peppercorn demi cream, potato pave, grilled garlic buttered broccolini

Cottage Pie

$20.00
ground beef &vegetable stew, English peas, mashed potatoes, parmesan

Pasta

100 Acre Pesto Pasta (V)

$25.00
house-made pasta, 100 acre basil pesto, parmesan, roasted cremini mushrooms, red bell pepper coulis, bread crumbs, cured egg yolk

Desserts

Black Forest Roll

$11.00
chocolate cake, vanilla mousse, malted chocolate crumble, meringue mushrooms, dark chocolate sauce, kirsch soaked cherries
Butterscotch Miso Tart photo

Butterscotch Miso Tart

$12.00
hazelnut crust, ganache, miso caramel, sea salt, five-spice hazelnut ice cream, hazelnut brittle, candied hazelnut, butterscotch miso sauce, cocoa nib disc, whipped cream

Messy Romanoff

$10.00
strawberry cremeux, orange-fennel cake croutons, crumble vanilla meringue, orange chantilly, strawberry conserve, fennel pollen

Affogato

$9.00
vanilla gelato, espresso

Buttermint is open for Weekend Brunch service Saturday-Sunday from 9 a.m-2 p.m.

Favorites

The Buttermint Classic photo

The Buttermint Classic

$12.00
two eggs, choice of meat, crispy roti, side toast
Omelette Evalon photo

Omelette Evalon

$17.00
cremini mushrooms, baby spinach, laclare evalon cheese, truffle cream, watercress, side toast
The Mosaic Benedict photo

The Mosaic Benedict

$18.00
house crumpets, crispy hickory-smoked pork belly, poached eggs, hollandaise, petite salad
Buttermilk Waffle photo

Buttermilk Waffle

$14.00
fresh mixed berries, lemon creme anglaise, whipped cream, little man syrup. OR caramel, crumbled bacon, roasted pecans, little man syrup
Tofu Scramble photo

Tofu Scramble

$16.00
curry sweet potatoes, wild rice, heirloom tomatoes, spinach, pseudo sauce
Brisket Brunch Burger photo

Brisket Brunch Burger

$17.00
1/3 lb. patty, duroc bacon, fried egg, american, L.T.O, house pickles, fries

Smoked Walleye Cakes

$15.00
poached eggs, brown butter and herb hollandaise, fried capers, marble potatoes, arugula

Classics

Milanese photo

Milanese

$21.00
breaded chicken breast, asparagus & endive, fried eggs, grain mustard sauce, lemon
Steak Diane photo

Steak Diane

$23.00
eye of strip loin, fried eggs, cognac mushroom cream sauce, watercress, side toast

Apple Lemon Risotto

$18.00
roasted apples, house smoked bacon, baby arugula, poached egg, parmesan, herb toast
Chicken a la King photo

Chicken a la King

$19.00
creamy chicken stew, crumpets, 100 acre petite salad, poached egg, truffle hollandaise

Lighter Fare

Avocado Toast photo

Avocado Toast

$14.00
soft egg, toasted sourdough, pickled chilies, watercress, pumpkin seeds, red wine syrup

Grand Toast

$14.00
tomato jam, persian feta, chopped bacon, arugula, crispy shallots, rosemary salt, white balsamic, whole grain bread

Deviled Eggs (3)

$10.00
chopped bacon, tobiko

Oysters of the Day

$19.00
Chebooktook - New Brunswick, fresh horseradish, house cocktail, lemon

Lyonnaise Salad

$14.00
100 acre mesclun, house cured bacon, poached egg, toast points, sherry vinaigrette

Pastry & Sweets

Giant Cookies photo

Giant Cookies

$4.00
Warm Sour Cream Donuts photo

Warm Sour Cream Donuts

$6.00
Powdered, chocolate sauce, brandy, creme anglaise

Butterscotch Miso Tart

$7.00
miso caramel, five spice ice cream, chocolate tuile

Essential Beverages

Classic Bloody Mary photo

Classic Bloody Mary

$10.00
wheatly vodka, house-made mix, celery, olive, pickle, spotted cow chaser

French 75

$9.00
tanqueray gin, lemon, simple syrup, prosecco

Morning Dove

$10.00
reposado tequila, amaro, lemon, maple syrup

Mimosa

$8.50
prosecco, fresh OJ

Aperol Spritz

$10.00
prosecco, aperol, soda, orange
Salty Dog photo

Salty Dog

$8.50
wheatley vodka, fresh grapefruit juice, half salted rim, rosemary

Coffee Alexander

$9.00
brandy, créme de cacao, valentine coffee

Shined-Up Coffee

$8.00
valentine coffee with choice of bourbon creme, amaretto cream, irish cream, or rumchata

Lunch box

$7.00
spotted cow, amaretto, orange juice
  • Reserve
  • Catering
  • Jobs