Skip to Main Content
Buttermint logo topButtermint logo scroll
  • (414)-488-2587
  • info@blackshoehospitality.com
  • 4195 N Oakland Ave , Shorewood
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • RESERVE
  • SPECIALS
  • OFF-SITE CATERING
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • CARRYOUT
  • Facebook pageInstagram page
Buttermint logo topButtermint logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • RESERVE
  • SPECIALS
  • OFF-SITE CATERING
  • PRIVATE PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • CARRYOUT

Our Menu

DinnerBrunch

Served 5-9pm Monday, Wednesday through Saturday.

Appetizers

Fried Cheese Curds

$10.00
spotted cow-battered clock shadow cheese curds, miso ranch dressing

Wings (x6)

$12.00
Buttermint Style - Maple BBQ - or Seoul-Full: with celery cucumber, creamy blue cheese dipping sauce

Hooks Cheddar Bacon Fries

$9.00
house-made white cheddar sauce, cherry wood bacon, avocado

Chicken Liver Mousse

$12.00
pickled shallots, port wine jelly, rye crostini

BSB Soft Rye "Pretzel" Loaf

$9.00
blended mustard, buttermint port wine cheese spread

Deviled Eggs (x3)

$8.00
bacon, chives

Chickpea Fries

$12.00
harissa, salt, pepper

Parker House Rolls (x4)

$6.00
sweet cream butter, course salt

Fried Brussels Sprouts

$12.00
sumac, caesar dressing, dried cranberries, chopped bacon, sunflower seeds, montamore cheese

Ricotta Meatballs (x3)

$12.00
beef & pork, focaccia, zesty marinara, parmesan crema

Fried Calamari

$14.00
banana peppers, onions, lemon, preserved lemon aioli

Oysters of the Day (x6)

$15.00
fresh horseradish, house cocktail, lemon

Oysters Rockefeller (x3)

$13.00
pernod, spinach, bacon, fennel, breadcrumb, hollandaise

Shrimp Cocktail (x5)

$12.00
large white gulf shrimp, lemon cream, house cocktail

Today's TV Dinner

(Wednesdays Only)

Today's TV Dinner photo

Today's TV Dinner

$23.00
spaghetti and meatballs, tomato gravy, BSB focaccia, green beans, banana & chocolate bread pudding with walnuts, whipped cream, and dark chocolate sauce

Salads & Soup

House Salad

$12.00
mixed greens, bacon, cucumber, tomato, avocado dressing, croutons

Sliced Tomato Salad

$12.00
stracciatella, pickled red onion, 100 acre fresh balsamic, parmesan vinaigrette, croutons

Tempura Squash Salad

$14.00
delicata, arugula, almonds, carrot ginger dressing, buttermilk blue cheese

Buttermint Waldorf

$13.00
fennel & frisée, maple spiced pepitas, grapes, apple, lemon apple dressing, shoestring sweet potato

*Add to your salad

$3.00/Avocado
$6.00/Grilled Portobello
$6.00/Grilled or Crispy Chicken
$9.00/Seared Steelhead Trout
$13.00/Bavette Steak 6 oz

Roasted Corn Bisque

$7.00

Mains

Seared Beef Short Rib

$29.00
smoked tomato braise, cheddar polenta, fall veggie giardinera

Steak & Eggs

$19.00
6 oz choice chuck filet, blue cheese hollandaise, fried eggs, fries, side toast, 100 acre greens salad

Chicken

$21.00
fried airline breast, green beans, mashed potatoes, biscuit, honey butter

Steelhead Trout

$29.00
roasted red pepper romesco, pistachios, & pine nut chimichurri, shoestring potatoes, trout roe

Great Lakes Walleye

$30.00
pretzel-crusted, potato pancake, house tartar sauce, lemon wedge, apple "beer" blanc sauce

Seared Sea Scallops

$30.00
saffron risotto, bacon-roasted croutons, spinach, lemon emulsion

CAB Filet Mignon - 8 oz

$46.00
topped with herb butter, choice of potato

Prime New York Strip - 13 oz

$47.00
topped with herb butter, choice of potato

Wood-Grilled BBQ Pork Ribs

$24.00/half rack
$32.00/full rack
maple bbq, fries, broccoli slaw

12 oz Duroc Pork Chop

$27.00
lardon, sweet potato puree, apple mustard gastrique, sautéed brussels sprouts

Portobello Steak

$21.00
twin caps in garlic and herbs, spinach, roasted turnips, mashed potatoes

Sandwiches

with crispy fries and house pickle

Classic Cheeseburger

$13.00
1/3# hereford chuck patty, american cheese, LTO, BSB bun

BBQ Bacon Burger

$15.00
1/3# hereford chuck patty, cheddar, maple bbq, bacon, haystack onions, LTO, BSB bun

"Old Fashioned" Uphoff Ham Sandwich

$13.00
aged gruyere, stone ground mustard, garlic aioli, pickled red onion, rye bread

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

$14.00
buttermilk fried bell and evans breast, LTO, chili-crisp mayo, BSB bun

Muenster Melt

$13.00
grilled portobello, sauteed beer onions, peppercorn mayo, muenster, sourdough

Avocado BLT

$13.00
smashed avocado, cherry wood bacon, tomato, lettuce, peppercorn mayo, sourdough

Pasta

Shrimp Linguine

$24.00
gulf shrimp, linguine, roasted tomatoes, spinach, lemon cream sauce, montamore

Spaghetti Bolognese

$20.00
slow-simmered meat sauce of pork, beef, and bacon, tomatoes & white wine, parmesan

100 Acre Pesto Pasta (V)

$25.00
house-made pasta, 100 acre basil pesto, parmesan, roasted cremini mushrooms, red bell pepper coulis, bread crumbs, cured egg yolk

Orecchiette with Sausage and Rapini

$21.00
"Little Ears" pasta, hot italian sausage, rapini, roasted fennel, onions and peppers, white wine tomato sauce

Sides

Sides

Rosti Potato • Mashed Potatoes • Loaded Baked Potato • Crispy Fries • Sauteed Garlic Spinach • Pernod Creamed Spinach

Buttermint is open for Brunch service Saturday & Sunday from 10 a.m-2 p.m.

For Starters...

Warm Sour Cream Donuts

$6.00
Powdered, chocolate sauce, brandy creme anglaise

Giant Cookies

$4.00
brandy chocolate chunk & cream cheese stuffed carrot cake

Deviled Eggs (x3)

$8.00
bacon, chives

Salad & Soup

House Salad

$12.00
100 acre greens, bacon, cucumber, tomato, avocado dressing, croutons

Sliced Tomato Salad

$12.00
stracciatella, red onion, 100 acre fresh basil, parmesan vinaigrette

Add to your salad

$3.00/avocado
$6.00/grilled or crispy chicken
$6.00/grilled portobello
$9.00/seared steelhead trout
$13.00/6 oz chuck filet

Roasted Corn Bisque

$7.00

Buttermint Waldorf

$13.00
fennel & frisee, maple spiced pepitas, grapes, apple, lemon apple dressing, shoestring sweet potato

Brunch Favorites

The Buttermint Classic

$12.00
two eggs, choice of meat, crispy roti, side toast

Omelette Evalon

$18.00
spinach, roasted mushrooms, la clare evalon cheese, truffle cream, petite salad, toast

The Mosaic Benedict

$18.00
house crumpets, sauteed spinach, hot sauce tomato, smoked pork belly, poached eggs, hollandaise, 100 acre petite salad

Buttermilk Waffle

$14.00
seasonal specialty waffle (rotates) OR caramel, crumbled bacon, roasted pecans, little man syrup

Tofu Scramble (V)

$16.00
curry sweet potatoes, lentils, cherry tomato, spinach, pseudo sauce, side toast

Steak & Eggs

$17.00
6 oz. choice chuck filet, bleu cheese hollandaise, fried eggs, fries, side toast, 100 acre greens salad

Sandwiches

with crispy fries and house pickle

Classic Cheeseburger

$13.00
1/3# hereford chuck patty, american cheese, LTO, BSB bun

BBQ Bacon Burger

$15.00
1/3# hereford chuck patty, cheddar, maple bbq, bacon, BSB bun

"Old Fashioned" Uphoff Ham Sandwich

$13.00
aged gruyere, stone ground mustard, garlic aioli, pickled red onion, rye bread

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

$14.00
buttermilk-fried bell & evans breast, LTO, chili-crisp mayo, BSB bun

Muenster Melt

$13.00
grilled portobello, sauteed beer onions, peppercorn mayo, muenster, sourdough

Avocado BLT

$13.00
smashed avocado, cherrywood bacon, tomato, lettuce, peppercorn mayo, sourdough

Essential Beverages

Classic Bloody Mary

$10.00
wheatly vodka, house-made mix, celery, olive, pickle, spotted cow chaser

French 75

$9.00
tanqueray gin, lemon, simple syrup, prosecco

Morning Dove

$10.00
reposado tequila, amaro, lemon, maple syrup

Mimosa

$8.50
prosecco, fresh OJ

Aperol Spritz

$10.00
prosecco, aperol, soda, orange

Salty Dog

$8.50
wheatley vodka, fresh grapefruit juice, half salted rim, rosemary

Coffee Alexander

$9.00
brandy, créme de cacao, valentine coffee

Shined-Up Coffee

$8.00
valentine coffee with choice of bourbon creme, amaretto cream, irish cream, or rumchata

Lunch box

$7.00
spotted cow, amaretto, orange juice
  • Reserve
  • Catering
  • Jobs