Skip to Main Content
Buttermint logo topButtermint logo scroll
  • (414)-488-2587
  • info@blackshoehospitality.com
  • 4195 N Oakland Ave , Shorewood
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • BLACK SHOE CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • RESERVE
Buttermint logo topButtermint logo scroll
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • BLACK SHOE CATERING
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • RESERVE

Our Menu

Raw BarMenu

Our menu will change often based on creativity, and may be subject to change based on ingredient availability. Enjoying raw or undercooked meat, seafood, or eggs may affect your health.

Chilled Seafood

Hiramasa Crudo* photo

Hiramasa Crudo*

$18.00
Satsuma, apple, ginger, mint

Poached Egg & Caviar*

$14.00
Endive, dill, bacon, cream, brioche
Oysters of the Day photo

Oysters of the Day

$19.00/6
East Coast or West Cost

House-Smoked Sturgeon

$18.00
horseradish, caraway, rye

Yellow Tail Sashimi

$16.00
cucumber, carrot, ponzu, spicy mayo, fried shallots

Chilled Meats & Vegetables

Mushroom Tartare photo

Mushroom Tartare

$12.00
avocado mayo, pickles, rye crostini
Lamb & White Bean Salad photo

Lamb & White Bean Salad

$14.00
Tomato jam, feta, rosemary salt

Deviled Eggs (3)

$10.00
chopped bacon, tobiko
Smoked Gazpacho photo

Smoked Gazpacho

$9.00
cucumber, zucchini, red onion, tomato, olive oil

Caprese

$9.00
ciliegini mozzarella, confit tomato, basil, balsamic

Our menu will change often based on creativity, and may be subject to change based on ingredient availability. Enjoying raw or undercooked meat, seafood, or eggs may affect your health.

Appetizers

Crispy Chicken photo

Crispy Chicken

$13.00
XO, sesame napa salad
Veal Sweetbreads photo

Veal Sweetbreads

$17.00
Sautéed, with mushrooms (Photo by Angela Peterson/Milwaukee Journal Sentinel)
Fried Calamari photo

Fried Calamari

$16.00
Banana peppers, onions, lemon, preserved lemon aioli

Asparagus Hollandaise

$12.00
asparagus, hollandaise , parmesan bread crumbs
Okonomiyaki photo

Okonomiyaki

$14.00
Smoked steelhead, special sauce, bonito

Chickpea Fries

$11.00
Harissa, course salt, and pepper.

Bread Service

$9.00
House-made, daily selection, salted butter

Meatballs Diane

$15.00
elk, beef sirloin, pork belly, brandy cream sauce, cremini

Salads

House Salad

$11.00
Greens, bacon, cucumber, tomato, avocado dressing, croutons
Tempura Squash Salad photo

Tempura Squash Salad

$12.00
Delicata, arugula, almonds, carrot-ginger dressing, buttermilk blue cheese

Slow Beets

$13.00
La Clare Evalon, watercress, walnuts, rosewater vinaigrette

Seafood

North Atlantic Flounder photo

North Atlantic Flounder

$31.00
Potato puree, beans & cipollini onions, verjus butter

Arctic Char à la Bavarian

$27.00
Smoked pork lentils, swiss chard, chanterelle cream, pickled mustard seed.

Grilled Swordfish

$34.00
Stir-fried butternut, apple, and cabbage, sticky rice, black vinegar, green curry.

Seafood Vol Au Vent

$34.00
Puff pastry, smoked mussels, scallop, Scottish salmon, carrots, leeks, asparagus, and lobster sauce.

Meats

Roasted Breast of Amish Chicken

$27.00
Chicken sausage pelmeni, squash, spinach, lemon chicken jus
Grilled Iowa Pork Rib Chop photo

Grilled Iowa Pork Rib Chop

$34.00
Candied bacon, celery root hash, potato croquette, calvados reduction

Grilled Niman Strip Loin Steak

$46.00
Potato pave, grilled broccolini, red onion, peppercorn sauce

Brisket Burger

$16.00
Double 1/3 s, American, L.T.O., house bun, fries

Sauteed Veal Liver

$32.00
Baby spinach, black garlic mashed potatoes, port wine sauce.

Vegetarian

House Spun Pasta

$23.00
Braised greens, mushroom bolognese, rosemary oil, parmesan.

Risotto Primavera

$27.00
Shiitake, English peas, ramp oil, artichoke, asparagus, sun dried tomato, parmesan
  • Reserve
  • Catering
  • Jobs